What Are the Best Shoes for Flat Feet?

The best shoes for flat feet are the New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14, the New Balance FuelCell Walker Elite, and the Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2, because they pair reliable arch support with stable platforms and cushioning that helps control overpronation without sacrificing all-day comfort. Below, we break down why each model works so well for flat feet and how to choose the right one for your needs. Van Dyke & Bacon can help you get the perfect fit.

Why Flat Feet Need the Right Shoes

Flat feet, or fallen arches, allow the foot to collapse inward as you walk, which can strain the plantar fascia, ankles, knees, and even the lower back. The right shoe counters that inward roll with midfoot support and a stable base, while cushioning softens impact and keeps your stride smooth. If you’ve ever felt your feet “work overtime” in unsupportive sneakers or dress-casual shoes, that’s overpronation at play. Choosing footwear built to guide your foot forward can make a day on your feet feel dramatically easier.

Key Features to Look For

When evaluating shoes for flat feet, three features rise to the top: a firm yet comfortable arch that resists collapse, a structured heel that keeps the rearfoot aligned, and cushioning that absorbs shock without feeling mushy. Materials matter, too; denser foams along the medial side, secure midfoot wraps, and durable rubber outsoles all contribute to long-term stability. A roomier toe box is a plus if your forefoot splays with each step, and removable insoles allow for custom orthotics when needed.

New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14

The Fresh Foam X 860v14 is a cornerstone stability shoe and a standout pick if your flat feet demand guidance on walks, runs, or long days on hard floors. The star of the show is New Balance’s Fresh Foam X midsole. It provides a cushioned, slightly lively ride while using strategic geometry to help limit overpronation. The platform feels planted and confidence-inspiring, especially through the midfoot where flat-footed wearers often need the most help.

A defined heel counter locks the rearfoot into place so your ankle stacks more naturally over the shoe. Through the midfoot, the upper’s structure works with the midsole to keep the arch supported without creating a hard “ridge” underfoot. The transition from heel to toe is smooth and consistent, which helps reduce lower-leg fatigue for walkers and runners alike.

Comfort is a priority here. The engineered mesh upper breathes well and conforms to a range of foot shapes, and the overall fit tends to be secure in the heel with accommodating volume up front. If you use custom orthotics, the removable insole makes swaps simple. For flat-footed walkers who also run or hit higher daily step counts, the 860v14 is the “do-everything” stability option that won’t feel stiff or clunky.

New Balance FuelCell Walker Elite

If your flat feet prefer a shoe that feels light and energetic during errands, travel, or long walks, the FuelCell Walker Elite brings performance-runner DNA into a polished walking package. FuelCell foam is known for its responsive, slightly springy feel. In the Walker Elite, that energy return is paired with a supportive chassis that quietly reins in overpronation so you feel propelled forward without wobble.

The walker-focused outsole geometry encourages a smooth roll from initial contact through toe-off. A supportive midfoot wrap and structured heel add the right kind of security for flat arches, while the upper offers a clean, versatile look you can wear with athleisure or casual outfits. For many shoppers, the Walker Elite hits a sweet spot: lighter on the foot than traditional stability trainers, yet still stable enough for long days at the office, theme-park marathons, or urban commutes.

Flat-footed wearers who are sensitive to harsh or overly firm support elements will appreciate how the Walker Elite blends guidance with comfort. The shoe doesn’t force your foot; it cues a better path with cushioning that keeps you fresh from morning to night.

Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2

Flat feet don’t take a break when you step out of athletic shoes, and that’s where the Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2 earns its place. It’s a dress-casual sneaker that delivers the polished vibe you want for the office or a night out, with under-the-hood support your arches actually need.

The Prentiss 2 uses a cushioned, supportive footbed that cradles the arch and helps maintain better alignment during the gait cycle. The midsole feels more substantial than typical lifestyle sneakers, giving you shock absorption closer to what you’d expect from a comfort brand without the “running shoe” look. A structured heel adds subtle stability, and the outsole has enough rubber coverage for grip and longevity.

The leather or refined textile uppers elevate everything you wear, from chinos to dark denim. This is a crucial advantage for flat-footed shoppers who dress smart-casual but can’t tolerate minimal support. With the Prentiss 2, you can keep your look sharp without inviting foot fatigue by lunchtime.

How These Three Compare for Flat Feet

All three shoes support flat arches, but they shine in different roles. The Fresh Foam X 860v14 is your premium stability workhorse when you log serious steps, train, or simply want maximum guidance without bulk. The FuelCell Walker Elite feels lighter and more dynamic, perfect for all-day urban walking or travel when you want energy and support in equal measure. The Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2 is the dress-casual option that keeps your feet aligned during client meetings, dinners, and weekends out.

If you wear orthotics, both New Balance models handle inserts easily thanks to removable insoles and generous internal volume. The Prentiss 2 is also orthotic-friendly in most fits, but the exact pairing depends on your orthotic thickness and the specific upper configuration. This is where an in-store fit session pays off.

Fit Tips for Flat Feet

Flat feet often benefit from a snug heel, secure midfoot, and more room in the forefoot. That combination minimizes slipping while allowing natural toe splay. If your arches collapse heavily, you may need a slightly firmer platform and a bit less softness under the medial side. If you’re new to supportive shoes, expect a short break-in as your feet adjust to better alignment; any pressure should be mild and temporary. Persistent hot spots or arch discomfort are signs to tweak size, width, or model.

New Balance produces multiple widths, which is a huge advantage for flat-footed shoppers with wide forefeet or bunions. Johnston & Murphy’s last is generally foot-friendly as well, but exact fit varies by upper material. Trying on both your measured size and the half-size up is smart, especially if you plan to add an insole or orthotic.

When to Choose Each Shoe at Van Dyke & Bacon

Choose the Fresh Foam X 860v14 if your priority is the most robust stability for training, high step counts, or demanding workdays on hard floors. You’ll appreciate its planted feel and dependable guidance mile after mile.

Pick the FuelCell Walker Elite if you want an energized walking experience that still protects flat arches. It’s ideal for commuters, travelers, hospitality professionals, teachers, and anyone who values a lighter, responsive ride without giving up support.

Select the Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2 when your calendar calls for smart-casual style and your feet demand real comfort. It bridges weekdays and weekends seamlessly and lets you dress up without stressing your arches.

The Bottom Line

If you’re asking “what are the best shoes for flat feet,” three clear winners rise to the top at Van Dyke & Bacon: New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14 for maximum stability and mileage, New Balance FuelCell Walker Elite for energetic, all-day walking support, and Johnston & Murphy Prentiss 2 for dress-casual polish that still protects flat arches. With the right guidance and a proper fitting, you’ll feel the difference immediately. Stop by Van Dyke & Bacon or shop online to find your perfect fit!